Login
Lexicon
Transformers Fanfics, Essays, Author Interviews and More...! Established 1996!
Firestorm [Contact]
09/12/02






[Report This]


Stories by Firestorm [823]
Firestorm's Favorites [0]
Reviews by Firestorm


Prometheus by Rob_Jung

Rated: G • starstarstarstarhalf-star
Summary: A group of humans petition for the release of Cybertronian technology to help solve Earth's problems, and Megatron sees an opportunity to be exploited.
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 07/01/03 Title: Chapter 1: Prometheus

Nothing against you, Rob, but the sequence at the end with Cooper being pumped by the government for the data ruined the flow of the story.



Decoy by Dave_Van_Domelen

Rated: G • starstarstarstar
Summary: An interesting theory about Beast Wars Megatron's true identity.
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: 18/12/03 Title: Chapter 1: Decoy

Perfect.



Death's Lessons by Nightwind

Rated: G • starstarstarstarhalf-star Feature
Summary: Ratchet rages against the injustice of war, as he watches a young girl he is unable to save.
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarstarhalf-star
Date: 18/08/03 Title: Chapter 1: Death's Lessons

Despite the overtones of what was happening, I found it almost a little bland in areas. I hate to say this but at times it almost looked like the base idea was taken from some old eps of MASH rather than TF.



Upon Further Review: Generation One Season Three by Scott_Kampa

Rated: G • starstarstarstarhalf-star
Summary: Scott Kampa defends the third season of Generation One cartoons.
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: 10/12/02 Title: Chapter 1: Upon Further Review: Generation One Season Three

An intelligent look at a subject that many often ignore. Good work!



We Didn't Start The Newsgroup by Scott_Kampa

Rated: G • starstarstarstar
Summary: Homage to Transformers newsgroups.
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 07/01/03 Title: Chapter 1: We Didn't Start The Newsgroup

I couldn't follow the beat after the first part.



Beast Machines: The Real Ending by Steven_Acevedo

Rated: G • starhalf-star
Summary: What Steve believes should really have happened.
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarhalf-star
Date: 16/01/03 Title: Chapter 1: Beast Machines: The Real Ending

Believe it or not, this was the more likely ending. At least, from what little of the series I dared to see.



S And H by Dave_Van_Domelen

Rated: G • starstarstarstar
Summary: Sometimes you get the bear, sometimes the bear gets you. This tale is lighter in tone than the two above, and stars Defcon, a character who appeared in one episode of the cartoon.
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: 18/12/03 Title: Chapter 1: S And H

LOL.



Having A Life Outside Of Transformers by Steven_Acevedo

Rated: G • starstarstarstarhalf-star
Summary: Is there life outside of the TV show, comic book and toyline. Here's how I view the whole matter when it comes to non-fans telling me or anyone else how we should be spending our lives.
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: 28/02/03 Title: Chapter 1: Having A Life Outside Of Transformers

Now if only I could get my mom to read this. What's even worse than a TF-hater? An anime hater.



Boredom by Dave_Van_Domelen

Rated: G • starstarstarstarhalf-star
Summary: What happens when a godlike being gets bored?
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 18/08/03 Title: Chapter 1: Boredom

Honestly, after reading it I felt that the flow was a little off-kilter. It's as if the story can't decide whether or not it's an essay or a work of fiction. Otherwise it would have been perfect.



Decisions by Neale_Davidson

Rated: G • starstarstarstarhalf-star
Summary: The kids decide to find other minicons to hide them from the Autobots and Decepticons, but Cyclonus finds them instead.
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarstarhalf-star
Date: 10/07/03 Title: Chapter 1: Decisions

While having it in the format of a script does make it easier to read, personally I'd rather have it in the normal (paragraph) format.



To Be Guardians by Neale_Davidson

Rated: G • starstarstarstar
Summary: Desperate to claim the Street Action minicons, the Decepticons capture Carlos and Rad, forcing the Minicons to make a terrible choice - their freedom, for that of their human friends.
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: 10/07/03 Title: Chapter 1: To Be Guardians

Methinks that I'm the only one who caught the 'Army of Darkness' references.....



Minicon Sale by Neale_Davidson

Rated: G • starstarstarstarhalf-star
Summary: Someone's been selling advanced weaponry in the Columbian drug wars, so the Autobots and Decepticons think that maybe, just maybe, there may be a rogue Minicon involved.
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 11/07/03 Title: Chapter 1: Minicon Sale

It feels as if, compared to the first four parts of the series, this one was a little rushed in the creation. There were also a few technical glitches (spacing issues, wording) that detracted from it.



Legends and Artifacts - I by Neale_Davidson

Rated: G • starstarstarstarhalf-star
Summary: Having nightmares of the past, Rad is coming to grips with a new sense of identity, a fact not lost on his father, or the military organization that he works for. Rad's father seems to know more about the Autobot-Decepticon conflict than he's let on, even
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 25/07/03 Title: Chapter 1: Legends and Artifacts - I

For once, there actually wasn't anything worth getting excited about.



Unlike Minds by Neale_Davidson

Rated: G • starstarstarstar
Summary: Sideways has been hired to steal the damaged Minicon pods from the Decepticon's base. But, when he hears how valuable they may be, he gets plans in mind of his own.
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 30/07/03 Title: Chapter 1: Unlike Minds

The typos and scripting glitches are getting to be a dissappointment.



Light of Justice, Flickering by Neale_Davidson

Rated: G • starstarstarstarhalf-star
Summary: With the battle over for the moment, the Autobots and Humans lick their wounds and come to grips with the losses they've endured.
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 25/07/03 Title: Chapter 1: Light of Justice, Flickering

I almost hate to say this but this one was bordering on the bland. I really think that by putting it in the format of a script instead of as a normal story is making things too rigid.



Swashbuckling by Neale_Davidson

Rated: G • starstarstarstarhalf-star
Summary: The Decepticons discover yet another Minicon team by accident. This time, though, the Air Defense team rush to the rescue, only to find that this team of Minicons don't really want to be rescued.
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarstarhalf-star
Date: 03/08/03 Title: Chapter 1: Swashbuckling

It takes some guts to pass off Princess Bride as being a part of Three Musketeers. However, I would appreciate it if the Acts were subdivided into Scenes for easier reading.



Fire in the Heavens - II by Neale_Davidson

Rated: G • starstarstarstarhalf-star
Summary: Optimus Prime faces Jetfire in a deadly battle of revenge. Rad confronts the Minicons that plague his memories, but will he kill a defeated foe? All this, and Starscream is ready to make his move at last.
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 30/09/03 Title: Chapter 1: Fire in the Heavens - II

In this one, I saw a major scripting error (blending one person's action sequence right after another person is talking). In addition, the speed of some of the incidents (mainly with Rad and the Super Fire Convoy bit) were at best jerky due to how they were handled.



Legacy by Pitten

Rated: G • starstarstarhalf-star
Summary: When you are bound by another's legacy, where do you place yourself in the grand scheme of the universe? A Megatron fic.
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarstarhalf-star
Date: 07/02/03 Title: Chapter 1: Legacy

Much better; not as forceful and with a much smoother progression to the epiphany.



Tell Me I Was Dreaming by Liana_Bluestar

Rated: G • starstarstarstarstar
Summary: The fight that sealed Ironhide and Chromia's relationship. What was it about?
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: 30/12/03 Title: Chapter 1: Tell Me I Was Dreaming

Nice, lite, and simple.



Optimus Primal Goes To Hell by OptimalLioConvoy

Rated: G • starstarstarhalf-star
Summary: So what happened to Optimus after he died? Will Hasbro snatch him away from the Matrix and make him endure a fate worse than death?
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 16/01/03 Title: Chapter 1: Optimus Primal Goes To Hell

I figured Beast Machines was a marketing ploy.



The Girl Who Loved Starscream by Negaprion

Rated: G • starstarstarstar
Summary: An injured Starscream is repaired by a mysterious woman who changes his outlook on life.
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 26/12/02 Title: Chapter 1: The Girl Who Loved Starscream

To put it simply, I feel that it could have stood another revision. The events seemed to just happen too quickly, for such a major awakening in a character. Had it been a minor awakening, or had there been a recommendation for something related (say, a song to listen to to get the proper mood), then it would have worked.



The Springer Show by Grendel

Rated: G • starstarstarhalf-star
Summary: The Jerry Springer Show, transformers-style.
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarhalf-star
Date: 19/01/03 Title: Chapter 1: The Springer Show

Needs to be a little longer.



Dolly Doesn't Want to Play by Pitten

Rated: G • starstarstarstarhalf-star
Summary: Following the death of Optimus Prime, Elita-One reflects on her life and makes a disturbing epiphany about the nature of relationship with the Autobot leader and society in general. Warning: Not a fluffy love story.
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarhalf-star
Date: 29/01/03 Title: Chapter 1: Dolly Doesn't Want to Play

Ibsen, eh? IMHO, the both of you tried way too hard. While your point is valid, the tone with which it was delivered would otherwise turn people off before they have finished reading. And yes, I did read A Doll's House exactly one year ago.



Hot Shot and Sideburn's Comparison and Contrast by Blurr322

Rated: G • starhalf-star
Summary: An essay on the comparison on Armada's Hot Shot and RID's Sideburn.
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarhalf-star
Date: 08/02/03 Title: Chapter 1: Hot Shot and Sideburn's Comparison and Contrast

And your point was?



Cyclonus's Report by Neale_Davidson

Rated: G • starstarstarstarhalf-star
Summary: With the situation on Earth getting desperate for the Decepticons, Cyclonus gives a report back to Cybertron, explaining the Minicon war, and his take on recent events.
Reviewer: Firestorm Signed starstarstarstar
Date: 03/10/03 Title: Chapter 1: Cyclonus's Report

The first two acts could have easily been told as a flashback sequence of some sort in a seperate work, most likely with Prime telling the kids what happened. This way, Cyclonus' report itself could have been focused almost entirely on what has been happening in your version of the storyline. This in turn would have allowed you to do a better summary job. In addition, it bugs me how you simply dropped in Overload, Final Battle Prime, Trion, and XXaron like they were little more than prop names.